Robert Ramirez
Lifecycle Marketer
Engagement-Based Segmentation: Reducing Unsubscribes by 50%
The Challenge
At Vacasa, I identified an opportunity to improve customer lifetime value by rethinking how frequently we communicated with our email subscribers.
Our existing campaign cadence didn't sufficiently account for differences in customer engagement. Highly engaged customers and long-inactive subscribers could receive similar volumes of marketing communications, potentially contributing to unnecessary unsubscribes.
High-volume email deployments also presented infrastructure challenges for our product team.
The goal: Develop a more intelligent, behavior-based sending strategy that would reduce unsubscribes and operational strain without sacrificing revenue.
The Strategy: Let Customer Engagement Drive Frequency
I developed an engagement-based segmentation strategy combining historical purchasing behavior and email activity to set the pace for marketing frequency.
Drawing on my experience with Vacasa's customer behavior and business cycles, I established inactivity thresholds for three audience groups. I then validated these thresholds against actual customer data, evaluating segment sizes to ensure each audience was large enough to support a practical and sustainable campaign strategy.
The resulting segments were:
Active Customers
Customers demonstrating recent purchase activity or email engagement who would continue receiving our regular marketing cadence.
Unengaged Customers
Customers showing declining engagement who would receive a reduced email cadence to limit fatigue while preserving opportunities for reengagement.
Ghosts
Customers with extended periods of inactivity who would be excluded from a large majority of regular promotional sends, creating a dedicated audience for future winback initiatives.
Execution: Building Scalable Lists from SQL and Automations
I led the technical implementation in Salesforce Marketing Cloud, translating the segmentation strategy into an automated, repeatable process. Required data from the warehouse had already been set up to flow into Marketing Cloud in a previous project.
1. Building and validating the segmentation logic
I developed SQL to classify customers using purchasing and engagement signals. I used AI as an additional quality-assurance resource to identify potential gaps and edge cases, then personally reviewed the final SQL and underlying customer data to validate the segmentation.
2. Automating audience management
I configured Salesforce Marketing Cloud automations to build and maintain the sendable data extensions for each engagement group, enabling segments to stay current as customer behavior changed. Extra contact center fields were added as well for future filterable workflows.
3. Redesigning campaign operations
I partnered with my team to establish an appropriate send frequency for each audience and created a flexible scheduling framework within our project management software, Asana.
This allowed our team to operationalize the new cadence while maintaining visibility into campaign planning and execution.
4. Launching and measuring performance
After deploying the new segmentation and scheduling approach, I monitored campaign performance over the following four months, evaluating unsubscribe trends, revenue, and operational impact.
The Results
~50% Lower Unsubscribe Rate
Over the four-month monitoring period, unsubscribe rates declined by approximately 50%, accounting for seasonal trends. Importantly, we maintained revenue while reducing unnecessary email exposure.
Reduced Infrastructure Strain
By distributing campaign volume more strategically, we reduced the burden of high-volume sends on our product team's infrastructure.
New Winback Opportunities
Separating long-inactive subscribers into a dedicated Ghosts audience created a foundation for future reactivation campaigns rather than continuing to include these customers in routine promotional sends.
Key Takeaway
This project demonstrated how effective lifecycle marketing requires more than campaign execution. By connecting customer behavior, technical automation, and operational strategy, I developed a scalable framework that improved the subscriber experience while supporting business performance.
The biggest lesson: Sending smarter can be more valuable than sending more.